MADRID (By Alan Riding, NYTimes)
May 8, 2008 — As a way of gauging the flows of artistic influence and
inspiration, it has become quite the fashion for exhibitions to juxtapose
well-known painters. Thus, recent shows like "Manet-Velázquez," "Van
Gogh-Gauguin" and "Picasso-Ingres" have led to, say, "Turner-Whistler-Monet,"
soon to travel from Paris to London, and to "Degas, Sickert and
Toulouse-Lautrec," to be seen next fall at Tate Britain.
But in its current show, the Prado Museum
in Madrid has reached still further. "The Spanish Portrait: From El Greco to
Picasso," which runs through Feb. 6, offers the first-ever overview of Spanish
portraits. More pertinently, by tracing a line that links old and modern masters
across no fewer than five centuries, the Prado is claiming that Spain's painters
make up a distinct category in the history of portraiture.
Certainly, no other museum could organize
this exhibition, not only because Velázquez's group portrait, "Las Meninas," the
crown jewel of the Prado's collection, cannot travel, but also because many
works by the pillars of the show - El Greco, Velázquez, Goya and Picasso - are
immediately at hand (in the case of Picasso, at the nearby Reina Sofia National
Museum Art Center). That said, almost half the 87 paintings on display are on
loan.
For this, the Prado offers a unique
setting. Within three years, its exhibitions will be presented in a new annex,
now under construction. But for the moment they "squat" inside the museum
itself, temporarily evicting works normally displayed in its long central
gallery. As a result, visitors leaving "The Spanish Portrait" step almost
seamlessly into the rest of the collection, blurring the artificial line that so
often isolates exhibitions.
In fact two galleries are open to visitors
to both exhibition and collection. In the Salón de Actos, "Las Meninas" hangs in
its traditional central place, although this rotunda now also contrasts
Velázquez and Goya. In another there are four large equestrian portraits, one by
Titian, two by Rubens and one by Velázquez. And in each case visitors can either
seek out more Titian, Rubens, Velázquez and Goya in the collection or step back
into the different logic of the exhibition.
"The Spanish Portrait" is presented
chronologically, underlining its central thesis of continuity through a few
exceptions, like having Velázquez's "Queen Mariana of Austria" and Picasso's
"Woman in Blue" face each other across the years. The show's story, though,
begins with religious paintings, with late 15th-century artists like Pedro
Berruguete already giving personality to names from the distant past.
While religious painting continued into the
20th century, secular portraits, notably of the monarchy, were more important in
establishing a Spanish style. The spark came from abroad - from Italy through
Titian and from Flanders through Anthonis Mor - but soon Spanish painters in the
court of Philip II, notably Alfonso Sánchez Coello and Juan Pantoja de la Cruz,
made their mark.
Spain's first great portraitist, Domenikos
Theotokopoulos, was himself born in Crete and studied in Italy before moving to
Spain, where he became known simply as The Greek, El Greco. Although widely
admired for his dramatic religious painting, his critical influence here was in
portraiture, not least because he broke free of the constraints of the royal
court by painting "civil portraits" of gentlemen in his home town of Toledo.
Renowned for the likenesses he achieved, El
Greco stands out today for the individuality he gives to subjects whose identity
is no longer important. To achieve this, he focused on the face, invariably
framed by a white ruffle collar, and the hands of those he painted. Indeed, it
is the dialogue between face and hand that distinguishes one of El Greco's most
famous portraits, "A Nobleman With His Hand on his Chest."
In two other portraits here, "Jerónimo de
Cevallos" and "An Elderly Gentleman," El Greco dwells only on the sad and solemn
faces of aging men. In contrast, "Friar Hortensio Félix Paravicino" exudes
energy and intelligence, as if the cleric, inblack and white robes, his left
hand marking the page of a book, has been unexpectedly interrupted in his
studies.
Oils by Ribera, Zurbarán and Murillo
confirm the new freedom enjoyed by early 17th-century Spanish portrait painters.
Ribera, who used ordinary Spaniards as the models for his great series of
philosophers and saints, traveled to Italy to paint "The Bearded Woman." And
typically, in "The Crucified Christ Contemplated by a Painter," Zurbarán
portrays himself as the painter.
Then, with the arrival of Velázquez in the
court of Philip IV, the genre reached new heights here. His early "civil
portraits" were influenced by El Greco, whose work he studied. He also reached
out to gentlemen, as in "Portrait of a Man"; dwarfs and buffoons, as in his
satirical "Democritus"; and celebrities, like "Luis de Góngora" and "The
Venerable Mother Jerónimo de la Fuente," in which the aged nun looks quite
irritated by the demands of the painter.
But it was as a court painter that
Velázquez made his name, bringing both remarkable technique and innovative
composition to what had long been formal and predictable royal portraiture. Two
portraits of Philip IV in this show capture the king 30 years apart, in both
cases dressed simply in black, with power and majesty conveyed through his face.
In contrast, in "Queen Mariana" Velázquez shows Philip's consort in full royal
finery.
One purpose of portraits was to present
future spouses to men they had not met. Nowhere was this more important that in
Velázquez's paintings of Philip's daughter, the Infanta Margarita, who was
engaged from an early age to her cousin, Leopold of Austria. The Prado exhibits
the magnificent "Infanta Margarita in Blue," but the child princess is also a
central figure along with Velázquez himself in "Las Meninas."
With its complex composition and teasing
mirror game spawning endless study and speculation since its completion in 1656,
"Las Meninas" was viewed by Velázquez as his masterpiece. Certainly its impact
on Goya more than a century later is made clear here in two group portraits,
"The Family of the Infante Don Luis" and "The Family of Charles IV." And, like
Velázquez in "Las Meninas," Goya includes himself in the two oils.
In fact, since both Velázquez and Goya were
court painters, the Prado can show how each tackled the same subject - the royal
family, the king on horseback, the king hunting, the queen in regal pose. Goya
also reached outside the monarchy, in one case painting "Francisco Cabarrús" in
a pose reminiscent of Velázquez's "Pablo de Valladolid." Goya in turn had his
own dark-eyed favorite, the Duchess of Alba, seen in two full-length portraits
here.
Goya's portraits and self-portraits - his
"Self-Portrait With Doctor Arrieta" here is notable - helped popularize
portraiture so that in the 20th century a score of Spanish artists could live
off the genre. Yet it was only at the turn of the century that Picasso restored
the link to Goya, Velázquez and El Greco - by acknowledging them as his masters
and imagining himself as their equal.
Just as his "Woman in Blue" recalls
Velázquez's "Queen Mariana" and his "Señora Canals" evokes Goya's "Queen María
With a Mantilla," just as his "Self-Portrait" as a bearded young man in 2001
seems to nod to Velázquez's "Portrait of a Man" painted 250 years earlier,
Picasso also shared the old masters' fascination with deformities, as apparent
in his one-eyed procuress, "La Celestina."
Yet, more than by technique and themes,
where the line from El Greco to Picasso is best established is in the
psychological realism of their subjects: notwithstanding how they looked in
life, they spring from the canvas as individuals today. Appropriately, Picasso,
whose work is being shown for the first time in the Prado, has the last word. In
one of his final self-portraits, he depicts himself as little more than a skull.
Yet barely a year before his death, his eyes still burn with passion.