Migrants Leaving Arizona
PHOENIX (Hispanic News) December 22, 2007 —
Undocumented immigrants in Arizona,
frustrated with a flagging economy
and tough new legislation cracking
down on their employers, are
returning to their home countries or
trying their luck in other states.
For
months, immigrants have taken a
wait-and-see attitude toward the state's
new employer-sanctions law, which takes
effect Jan. 1. The voter-approved
legislation is an attempt to lessen the
economic incentive for undocumented
immigrants in Arizona, the busiest
crossing point along the U.S.-Mexico
border.
And by all
appearances, it's starting to work.
"People
are calling me telling me about their
friend, their cousin, their neighbors —
they're moving back to Mexico," said
Magdalena Schwartz, an immigrant-rights
activist and pastor at a Mesa church.
"They don't want to live in fear, in
terror."
Martin
Herrera, a 40-year-old undocumented
immigrant and masonry worker who lives
in Camp Verde, 70 miles north of
Phoenix, said he is planning to return
to Mexico as soon as he ties up loose
ends after living here for four years.
"I don't
want to live here because of the new law
and the oppressive environment," he
said. "I'll be better in my country."
He called
the employer-sanctions law "absurd."
"Everybody
here, documented or undocumented, we
are part of a motor that makes this
country run," Herrera said. "Once we
leave, the motor is going to start to
slow down."
There's no
way to know how many undocumented
immigrants are leaving Arizona,
especially now with many returning home
for normal holidays visits. But
economists, immigration lawyers and
people who work in the immigrant
community agree it's happening.
State Rep.
Russell Pearce of Mesa, the author of
the employer sanctions law, said his
intent was to drive undocumented
immigrants out of Arizona.
"I'm
hoping they will self-deport," Pearce
said. "They broke the law. They're
criminals."
Under the
employer sanctions law, businesses found
to have knowingly hired undocumented
workers will be subject to sanctions
from probation to a 10-day suspension of
their business licenses. A second
violation would bring permanent
revocation of the license.
Nancy-Jo
Merritt, an immigration lawyer who
primarily represents employers, said her
clients already have started to fire
workers who can't prove they are in the
country undocumented.
"Workers
are being fired, of course," she said.
"Nobody wants to find out later on that
they've got somebody working for them
who's not here undocumented."
When
immigrants don't have jobs, they don't
stick around, said Dawn McLaren, a
research economist at Arizona State
University who specializes in
undocumented immigration.
She said
the flagging economy, particularly in
the construction industry, also is
contributing to an immigrant exodus.
"As the
jobs dwindle and the environment becomes
more unpleasant in more ways than one,
you then decide what to do, and perhaps
leaving looks like a good idea," she
said. "And certainly that creates a
problem, because as people leave, they
take the jobs they created with them."
Pearce
disagreed that the Arizona economy will
suffer after undocumented immigrants
leave, saying there will be less crime,
lower taxes, less congestion, smaller
classroom sizes and shorter lines in
emergency rooms.
"We have a
free market. It'll adjust," he said.
"Americans will be much better off."
He said
he's not surprised undocumented
immigrants are leaving the state and
predicts that more will go once the
employer-sanctions law takes effect next
month.
"It's
attrition by enforcement," he said. "As
you make this an unfriendly state for
lawbreakers, I'm hoping they will pick
up and leave."