he burst
of activism signals desperation among immigrants disappointed that a proposed
congressional overhaul of the immigration system collapsed in June. The plan
would have created a process for some illegal immigrants to earn legal status.
Spokesmen for illegal immigrants are looking
for whatever tactic is available. The normal legislative process hasn't worked
for them so far.
'Doing it in solidarity'
Immigrant leaders say boycotts are effective
because they prove that the economy would suffer without immigrant workers.
In Arizona, a law effect Jan. 1, for employers
who knowingly hire illegal immigrants can have their business licenses suspended
or revoked. Many say the law could be disastrous for the economy because
immigrants work low-paying but critical jobs at dairies, farms, construction
sites and elsewhere.
As local governments dabble in immigration
enforcement and in some cases train their police to be de facto immigration
agents, some legal immigrants are concerned they'll be targeted just as illegal
immigrants are, says Mauricio Vivero of Ayuda, a non-profit law firm for
immigrants in Washington, D.C.
Some legal immigrants believe businesses will
avoid hiring Hispanic workers altogether or that police will engage in racial
profiling, detaining people based on appearance, he says.
"There's fear in the community. People are
concerned they will be discriminated against," he says. "For a poor immigrant
who doesn't speak English but may be perfectly legal, they're concerned they may
be picked up."
Bill Hing, a law professor at the University of
California, Davis, who specializes in immigration, says legal immigrants are
participating because some of their loved ones are here illegally.
"The community is made up of a lot of mixed
families," Hing says. "There might be 10-to-13 million undocumented immigrants
in the United States. You can multiply that five or six times to determine the
number of people it affects, because of relatives and employers and co-workers
and friends. There are a lot of people frustrated that nothing was done" by
Congress.
Yesenia Rivas' family is an example. Twelve of
her relatives, legal and illegal immigrants from El Salvador, participated in
the Prince William boycott, she says. The guidelines were simple: Spend money
only at immigrant-owned businesses or those displaying a "pro-immigrant" poster.
"Some family members are illegal but have been
here most of their lives," she says. "My father is here legally now, but he was
here illegally for 20 years."
During the boycott, Rivas, 17, washed clothes
at a laundry that displayed the "pro-immigrant" sign. Her parents went to nearby
Fairfax County for groceries and gas. "We're doing it in solidarity," Rivas
says. "We understand what they're going through."
Boycotts can backfire
Do such boycotts work? That's debatable.
Hing says he hopes they have a noticeable
impact but acknowledges that such tactics don't always accomplish much.
"If they are unified and have a very large
boycott, it can be felt. That will catch people's attention," he says. "If it's
not massive or in a part of the country where there are not that many
immigrants, it's going to be mocked."
Immigrants in Waukegan have had a boycott going
since July 4. Organizers asked businesses to display a poster opposing a program
that trains local police to enforce federal immigration laws. Businesses that do
not display the sign are supposed to be avoided.
Alderman Sam Cunningham, who opposed the police
plan, says restaurant owners and developers have complained about the boycott.
"Every business that I've talked to said, 'We've lost business,' or people
aren't coming in."
Waukegan Mayor Richard Hyde believes the
boycott there backfired. He says Hispanic-owned businesses have taken the brunt
of the economic losses because shoppers who oppose illegal immigration have made
a point of avoiding stores that display the sign.
"It was disastrous for the Hispanic businesses.
It reversed on them," Hyde says. "The people who benefited were the white
businesses."
The activism is not limited to boycotts. The
National Coalition of Hispanic Clergy and Christian Leaders will hold a prayer
rally Sunday in Atlanta and one next month in Oklahoma City to protest state
immigration policies, says Miguel Rivera, president of the coalition. Rivera
says 38% of the coalition's church members are here illegally.
Wednesday's protests were called by Elvira
Arellano, a Mexican who took refuge in a Chicago church last year rather than
report for deportation. She left the church in August to attend rallies in Los
Angeles, where U.S. agents caught up with her and deported her.
Fears of being profiled
In Prince William County, the immigrant
population has ballooned alongside the population of professionals seeking
bigger, cheaper homes than those closer to Washington. Day laborers mill in
front of convenience stores, waiting for contractors and homeowners to drive by
and offer work. Shopping centers have Mexican bakeries as well as McDonald's
restaurants.
Immigrant activists have been particularly
critical of a part of the local resolution that requires police to check the
immigration status of anyone they detain if there is reason to believe the
person is undocumented. Officials haven't determined how they will do that.
"People are saying they feel targeted, afraid,
persecuted," says Ricardo Juarez of Mexicanos Sin Fronteras (Mexicans Without
Borders), which organized the boycott. His group is asking workers to stay home
from work Oct. 9.
"The purpose of the boycott isn't to punish the
residents and businesses in the community," he says. "The purpose is to show
that we contribute directly from our pockets, no matter what our status."
Corey Stewart, chairman of the Prince William
Board of County Supervisors, calls the boycott "foolish."
"If the boycott was meant to engender sympathy
or fear, what it has done is create a whole lot of anger toward the illegal
immigrant community and their supporters," Stewart says. "There is no excuse for
breaking the law."
He says illegal immigrants have crowded
hospitals, schools and homes in the county and contributed to a growing gang
problem. One-fifth of the county jail inmates are illegal immigrants, he says.
Angelica Fuentes counters that most illegal
immigrants are hard-working people who give more than they take. Fuentes, 25,
came to the USA illegally from Guatemala two years ago and participated in the
Prince William boycott.
"We have to say something, because we are
getting frustrated," she says. "Things are getting worse for us. In the past,
you could get a driver's license, you could get an apartment, you could get a
job. Now, you can't."
Fuentes has nine brothers and sisters in the
USA, four of them here legally. Some live in Los Angeles, some in Prince
William. All of her Virginia relatives joined the boycott, says Fuentes, who
works at a printing shop six days a week.
Thinking about her future in the United States,
she starts to cry.
"I am
so depressed about the situation that I don't feel human, sometimes," she says.
"They are right that we are not legal. We are wrong. But we are stealing
nothing. We work so hard. They need us."