PHOENIX (By Paul Giblin, NYTimes)
March 24, 2008 —
Scores of sheriff’s deputies,
assisted by civilian volunteers and
shadowed by observers from
immigration advocacy groups,
conducted saturation patrols this
weekend in neighborhoods where
illegal immigrants live, work and
worship.
The
authorities said that the initial
sweep, which began about sundown on
Friday, led to the arrests of nine
people who could not prove United
States citizenship and four other
people on unrelated charges like
outstanding warrants.
Deputies initially stopped motorists
on traffic violations and then asked
them for identification.
The
observers tried to ensure that
people snared in the operation were
treated properly by law enforcement
personnel under the direction of the
county’s hard-edged sheriff, Joe
Arpaio.
“The guy is completely attacking an
entire class of people based on
their color,” said Adolfo Maldonado,
an engineer who said he has trailed
sheriff’s deputies on patrol. “He’s
racial profiling.”
Sheriff Arpaio dismissed the
criticisms.
“We’re not going on the street
corner, grabbing 15 people because
they look like they came from
Mexico,” the sheriff said. “We don’t
do that. We only develop the illegal
immigration situation when we come
across people violating the law.”
The
Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office
began the patrols on Friday in
response to small-business owners
who complained that day laborers
loiter in the East Phoenix
neighborhood, harass customers and
leave litter, including beer cans.
Law enforcement officials set up a
command center and booking
facilities in a parking lot outside
a Goodwill store at a strip mall.
The
site in a working-class neighborhood
is just blocks from Pruitt’s
furniture store, which became a
flash point for the immigration
debate last year when a similar
operation by sheriff’s deputies
touched off protests on both sides
of the issue. In that operation, 134
people were arrested, 94 of whom
were determined to be in the country
illegally.
Melody Jafari, owner of Jafari
Chiropractic and Acupuncture, said
gangs of men standing outside her
business scared customers.
“All we want is even-handed
enforcement,” Ms. Jafari said. “The
same laws that apply for myself and
the businesses, we want them to
apply for everybody, and that
includes the men loitering on the
streets and trespassing and
soliciting and impeding traffic.”
Immigrant advocates who tried to
conduct their own news conference
just outside the command center were
interrupted by four people on
Harley-Davidson motorcycles adorned
with American flags. The cyclists
stopped their bikes and revved their
engines, making conversation
impossible.
On
the streets, it was easy for two of
the observers, Magdalena Schwartz
and Dan Peitzmeyer, to spot the
patrols.
They first saw two deputies outside
a check-cashing store, where they
stopped a woman they said had driven
through a red light.
The
woman told the observers that her
name was Paola Rodriguez and that
she was in the country illegally. By
that time, however, she had already
given the deputies her Mexican voter
identification card, making her
chances of being deported far more
likely. Deputies placed her in the
back of a patrol car and drove her
to the command center for
processing.
“My
issue is just respect and dignity,”
Mr. Peitzmeyer said. “Don’t be
abusive.”
Minutes later, two blocks away, Ms.
Schwartz and Mr. Peitzmeyer came
across another set of deputies who
had pulled over a vehicle at a
convenience store, where the driver
worked as a clerk. The deputies
stopped him for making an illegal
left turn.
Ms.
Schwartz approached him as he sat in
his vehicle and learned that his
name was Israel Salenas and that he,
too, was an illegal immigrant.
Before the deputies instructed her
to step away, she advised Mr.
Salenas to refuse to answer any
questions regarding his residency
status.
Deputies arrested him for driving on
a suspended driver’s license.
Sheriff Arpaio scoffed at the
suggestion he chose Easter weekend
to catch illegal immigrants headed
to church.
“I
don’t know if we should bring
religion into a political or law
enforcement operation,” he said. “We
work every day of the week. It
doesn’t matter what day it is. We
planned this awhile back, and I’m
not going to abort this operation
because some people might be
concerned it’s Good Friday.”