The committee agreed on a compromise
offered by the Michigan Democratic
Party that would give Clinton 69
delegates and Obama 59. Each
delegate would get half a vote at
the convention in Denver later this
summer.
They also
agreed to seat the Florida
delegation based on the outcome of
the January primary, with 105
pledged delegates for Clinton and 67
for Obama, but with each delegate
getting half a vote as a penalty.
The panel
easily reached a vote on the Florida
settlement, but the Michigan
situation proved stickier, passing
19-8. The vote caused audience
members to shout out in objection,
and at least a handful walked out of
the hall after the vote.
Clinton
supporters raised the specter of a
continued fight over Michigan.
"Hijacking
four delegates is not a good way to
start down the path of party unity,"
said Harold Ickes, Clinton's chief
delegate counter and a member of the
panel. "Mrs. Clinton has instructed
me to reserve her rights to take
this to the credentials committee."
Earlier,
Florida Rep. Robert Wexler, speaking
for Obama, called on the DNC Rules
and Bylaws Committee to seat the
state's 211 delegates — but with
only half their voting strength.
That would give Clinton 19 more
delegates than Obama from the state.
Those are equal to the number that
Clinton earned through victories in
Ohio and Pennsylvania, Wexler said.
"Senator
Obama should be commended for his
willingness to offer this
extraordinary concession," Wexler
said to applause and hisses from the
raucus crowd of supporters crowded
into a meeting room of a Washington
hotel to witness the meeting.
"Senator Obama offers the concession
in order to offer reconciliation
with Florida voters."
Sen. Bill
Nelson, a Clinton supporter speaking
on behalf of the state party, also
backed a plan to provide half the
delegate votes but full voting power
for the state's 26 party leaders and
elected officials known as
superdelegates.
Clinton's
campaign remained steadfast in its
push to seat the full delegation. "I
want it all," said Arthenia Joyner,
a state senator from the Tampa area
who spoke on Clinton's behalf. She
urged the panel to "give voices back
to the 1.75 million voters in
Florida" so Democrats can "leave the
room today, hand-in-hand, joining
together and focused on victory in
November."
Resolving the
Michigan dispute has proved thorny
for the committee. Clinton was the
only major candidate on the ballot
in the state's Jan. 15 primary, and
prevailed over "uncommitted."
Mark Brewer,
the state party chairman, urged the
panel to grant 69 of the state's 128
pledged delegates to Clinton and 59
to Obama.
Former
Michigan congressman David Bonior,
speaking for Obama, said the
delegates should be split evenly,
calling it the "only apprioriate and
fair way" to resolve the dispute.
Under that scenario, each candidate
would get 64 delegates.
The Clinton
campaign is pushing for a 73-55
split with Obama, in accordance the
state's primary results.
"You've got
to honor the 600,000 voters in
Michigan," former Michigan Gov,
James Blanchard, a Clinton
supporter, told the panel. "If you
turn your back on the voters of
Michigan and Florida, you will be
flirting with a McCain victory."
Blanchard
said the primary was not flawed, but
that other Democrats "had a flawed
strategy" because "neither the DNC
rules nor Michigan law … required
them to take their names off the
ballot."
Earlier,
Democratic National Committee
chairman Howard Dean told the panel
that their "actions today will put
us back on course for party unity."
He said
Democrats had endured a "very tough,
long difficult campaign, but it has
made our candidates much stronger."
Outside of
the hotel, a crowd waved homemade
signs and chanted "Every vote!"
Hotel security staff kept watch over
the crowd, shepherding people off
the hotel grounds at times.
By urging the
committee to seat all the delegates
from Michigan and Florida, Clinton
is trying to strengthen her argument
to uncommitted superdelegates that
she holds the lead in the popular
vote and is better positioned win
the general election.
Obama, who
leads in delegates and states won,
is 42 delegates shy of the 2,026
delegates now needed to clinch the
nomination. He also leads among
superdelegates — the party insiders
and elected officials who will
determine the winner of the closest
Democratic contest in two decades.
Beverly
Battelle Weeks, 56, a Clinton
delegate who got up well before dawn
to drive up from Richmond, Va.,
carried a black umbrella on which
she had pasted letters spelling out
"Count All Votes."
"The right
thing to do is to seat all the
delegates. Anything less is not
democratic," she said.
Tad Devine, a
Democratic strategist who is neutral
in the race, said he believed
Obama's nomination was inevitable.
The committee's decision will signal
whether "we see the beginning of the
party pulling behind the nominee or
the continuation of a long primary
battle that would go all the way to
the convention," he said.
Michigan and
Florida were stripped of their
delegates — 368 in total — for
holding their primaries early in
violation of party rules. Clinton
won both contests. Neither candidate
campaigned in the states before
their January contests. Obama also
took his name off the Michigan
ballot.
"We have
suffered horribly," said Jon Ausman,
a Democratic National Committee
member from Florida. He recommended
that the rules committee give all
his state's superdelegates a full
vote at the convention and grant
one-half vote to the rest.
The most
widely discussed compromise
envisioned granting seats to all
those delegates, but giving each
one-half a vote. That would satisfy
Clinton's call for all to be seated
without jeopardizing Obama's lead.
Party
leaders, such as Dean and House
Speaker Nancy Pelosi, are eager to
see a deal that brings a swift
resolution to their party's marathon
nomination fight. Democrats also
want to heal wounds among voters in
Florida and Michigan, both
battleground states in the November
general-election fight against
Republican presumptive nominee John
McCain.
Obama
campaign manager David Plouffe
earlier this week told reporters
that their camp is "willing to seat
some delegates...in the interest of
bringing this to resolution."
But Harold
Ickes, a member of the committee and
Clinton's chief delegate counter, on
Friday reiterated the campaign's
call that all it wants to see all
the delegates seated according the
results of the January contests in
each state.
The campaign
also took issue with a legal
analysis issued by DNC lawyers
earlier this week that said party
rules call for the two states to
lose at least half of their delegate
strength. A letter sent to the
committee Friday by Clinton's
general counsel Lyn Utrecht said the
panel "can and should seat all the
delegates" with "full votes."
Clinton's
aides concede she still will trail
Obama's delegate count even if she
prevails today. However, the number
needed to clinch the nomination is
expected to go up, depending on how
many delegates the committee seats.
That means Obama will have to win
over an increasing number of the
roughly 200 remaining uncommitted
superdelegates to lock up the
nomination.
Ickes and
other Clinton aides also have not
said whether they would stage a
credentials fight at the August
convention if they leave Saturday's
meeting with an unfavorable
decision. "We think it's not useful
to cross streams before we come to
them," Ickes said.
The 30-member
panel faces a full day as it weighs
its options.
"I've been to
a lot of rules committee meetings
and I never thought I'd live to see
them carried live on television,"
said Devine, who was a senior
adviser to Democrat John Kerry in
his 2004 White House bid.
"It's been an endlessly fascinating
process," he said of the drawn-out
nomination fight. "I think people
want to know if this thing is ending
or not."