Deported but Determined to Return
SANTA
TECLA, El Salvador (By Emily Bazar,
USA Today) — When Oscar Ordoñez, 56,
pleaded guilty to attempted theft in
Colorado, he didn't realize he could
lose his right to live in the USA.
Now he sits on his sister's balcony
overlooking the green Salvadoran
hills, dreaming of the life he left
behind and plotting his illegal
return.
Estella
Lemus, 27, cries as she describes the
hunger, danger and injuries of her
illegal border crossing and says she
won't do it again. The seamstress, who
earns up to $5 a day in her poor
neighborhood north of San Salvador,
worries about how she'll repay the
$3,000 her family borrowed for her trip.
Nearby,
Pedro Berrios, 25, reads to his
5-year-old son in their cinder-block
home next to the filthy Tomayate River.
Berrios will keep trying to enter the
USA illegally, he says, because "I don't
see another way out of here."
The lives
of Ordoñez, Lemus and Berrios converged
on Feb. 28 when they boarded a plane in
Texas with 116 other men and women. They
were being deported to El Salvador,
targets of the U.S. government's
crackdown on illegal immigrants.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement
(ICE) has been raiding job sites,
renewing its efforts to track down
illegal immigrants with criminal records
and stepping up deportations. Last year,
a record 282,548 illegal immigrants were
sent home, more than double the number
in 2001.
The
government limits legal immigration to
roughly 1 million people each year,
giving preference to relatives of U.S.
citizens. On top of that, it admits
800,000 or more people on temporary work
visas. Those limits mean immigrants such
as Ordoñez, Lemus and Berrios take their
chances and try to cross illegally,
sometimes again and again.
The
government ramped up deportations after
9/11 as part of a broad effort to secure
U.S. borders. Yet, as the Salvadorans'
stories show, the policy is up against
the economic reality of life in
developing countries. The three say they
went to the USA to escape poverty and
crime. Now that the deportation flight
has left them back in their homeland,
they say the same things may spur them
to try again.
"I don't
want to stay here," Ordoñez says. "In
the U.S., you have a chance to work and
buy whatever you need."
Charles
Kuck, president-elect of the American
Immigration Lawyers Association, says
illegal immigrants such as Ordoñez won't
stay in their homelands.
"They have
no reason to stay," he says. "Regardless
of how hard it is to make it here as an
immigrant, it is still better than being
back home."
Kuck says
Congress should allow more people to
enter legally.
Homeland
Security Secretary Michael Chertoff, who
oversees ICE, advocates expanding
temporary worker programs.
"Many of
these people would be happy to work and
go home again," he says. "It would
satisfy our economic needs and be humane
and law-abiding."
But for
now, Chertoff says, his department has
no choice.
"When we
find somebody who's here illegally, we
deport them," he says. "To fail to do
that essentially would be turning a
blind eye to a violation of the law."
Chertoff
says he knows most people who enter the
country illegally come to work and many
are fleeing difficult circumstances.
"But I can't condone their violation of
the law," he says. "However
heart-wrenching the motive is, it is
still a violation of the law to sneak
in."
72,000
deported by plane
ICE
deports illegal immigrants by land and
air. Most Mexican deportees are bused
across the border. Others are sent home
on commercial flights or government
charters. Last year, nearly 72,000
illegal immigrants were deported by
plane.
"For many
of them, it's the first time they've
ever been on an airplane," says Michael
Pitts, chief of the ICE Flight
Operations Unit.
Flying its
nine planes will cost ICE $135 million
this year, up from about $100 million
last year.
"We're
really serious about enforcing
immigration laws and securing our
borders," ICE spokeswoman Kelly Nantel
says.
On the
last Thursday morning of February, three
buses roll up to a Boeing 737 in
Harlingen, Texas.
One by
one, 38 women and 81 men step off the
buses, hands behind their heads, laces
removed from their shoes and belts from
their pants so they can't be used as
weapons. ICE officials frisk them and
check their shoes and mouths for drugs
and weapons.
Although
one of ICE's highest priorities is
deporting people with felony records,
most of these people had no criminal
convictions. Most were caught in Texas
trying to enter illegally and 23 had
been in the USA before, Nantel says.
The
flight, less than three hours, is quiet.
The passengers eat sandwiches and get
up, with supervision, for bathroom
breaks.
The plane
lands at the San Salvador airport at
about 11 a.m. One man steps into the
tropical air, throws his arms out wide
and yells "Home!" in English.
Economic, public safety effects
The
deportees are funneled into a processing
center at the airport, offered tetanus
shots and given a traditional Salvadoran
meal of pupusas, stuffed corn
tortillas. After being interviewed,
photographed and fingerprinted, they're
given up to $6 for bus fare and are free
to go.
The rising
flow of people deported from the USA has
had a dramatic effect on the economy and
public safety of this Central American
country of about 7 million people.
Nearly 20,000 Salvadorans were sent home
last year, up from about 11,500 in 2006.
"The
capacity of the United States to catch
people who are undocumented in the
country or who have committed crimes has
increased," says Rene León, El
Salvador's ambassador to the USA.
There are
about 2 million Salvadorans in the USA,
he says. Three-quarters are in the
country legally, he estimates.
Last year,
Salvadorans working abroad, most in the
USA, sent $3.69 billion home, equal to
about 18% of El Salvador's gross
domestic product, the central bank
reported.
Rising
deportations "will affect employment
here," immigration official Balbino
Velásquez says. "It will affect the
economy." Salvadorans who no longer
receive monthly wires of money from
relatives in the USA have less to spend,
and returning immigrants have trouble
finding jobs, he says.
The tide
of deportees also affects public safety.
Nearly one quarter of the immigrants
deported to El Salvador last year had
criminal records in the USA, from theft
and drug possession to violent crime.
León says there's a "positive, clear-cut
correlation" between the rise in
criminal deportees and a rise in crime
in El Salvador. Of particular concern
are gangs and organized crime networks,
he says.
Bob Dane,
spokesman for the Federation for
American Immigration Reform, which
advocates more border security and less
immigration, applauds the aggressive
deportation of immigrants with criminal
records.
"Countries
can't expect to export their criminals
without us sending them back," he says.
"America can't be a sanctuary for the
world's bad guys."
Jose
Castaneda, 34, was sent back to El
Salvador last April after getting out of
jail. He had joined his mother in Los
Angeles when he was 13. He became a
legal permanent resident but lost that
status after he was convicted of
possessing crystal meth. "When I got
here last year, I was lost," he says.
"I'm from here, but I was raised in the
USA."
Castaneda
lives with his aunt in the picturesque
town of Ataco and earns $3 a day
unloading trucks. He left behind four
children and a girlfriend in Las Vegas.
"I'm going to have to go back," he says.
"That's where my family is."
'I
don't have a choice'
About half
of Salvadoran deportees lived in the USA
more than five years, says Jesús
Aguilar, head of CARECEN International
in El Salvador, which advocates for
migrants.
Aguilar
believes most deportees try to return to
the USA because jobs at home are scarce
and many left family behind. But the
stakes are high. An illegal immigrant
who has been deported before risks a
felony conviction and up to 20 years in
prison if caught.
Ordoñez,
who lived in the USA more than 18 years,
isn't giving up. "My life is not here,"
he says of El Salvador. "My life is
there."
Ordoñez
finished the sixth grade and started
working at age 12. In his early 30s, he
went to the USA for the first time and
was caught three days later, kicking off
a cycle of illegal entries and run-ins
with the Border Patrol. He says he was
sent home 18 times, but government
records show he was officially deported
just once.
What
tenacity couldn't do for him, marriage
did. Ordoñez met Jean Gibson, an
American who helped Salvadorans fleeing
civil war. When he returned to El
Salvador in 2087, she followed and they
married. He got a waiver to immigrate
the next year and became a legal
permanent resident.
His
immigration troubles began not when the
couple divorced in 2094 but when he was
convicted of a felony in Colorado.
Ordoñez
was working as a janitor at a Cripple
Creek casino. In 2096, his landlords
accused him of stealing two rings and
other items. He says he didn't steal the
jewelry but that his landlady gave it to
him to sell. Acting on what he says was
bad advice from a public defender who
didn't advise him of the consequences to
his immigration status, Ordoñez pleaded
guilty in 2002 to attempted theft.
An
attorney helped Ordoñez get the case
dismissed and the felony erased from his
record in 2005, but it was too late. He
lost his legal status and returned to El
Salvador to live with his sister in
Santa Tecla.
He didn't
stay long. Last year, he was caught
twice trying to cross the border. He
spent four months in jail. Despite the
threat of a longer sentence if he's
caught again, he says he'll return. He
wants to earn money for his family in
Santa Tecla.
"I don't
have a choice," Ordoñez says. "Right
now, I don't have a life in this
country."
A
family's dream
Desperate
circumstances prompted Lemus to head for
the USA. Her father, Jorge Hernandez,
50, needs a $1,200 operation to remove a
tumor from his groin. Her mother, Maria
Reyna Lemus, 48, has diabetes and needs
insulin.
At 14,
Lemus began working as a seamstress in
her parents' home in Apopa, which has no
running water and at times is a haven
for roosters. On good days, she says,
she earned $5. She wanted to stay in
school, she says, but didn't have the
money for books and supplies.
Her
younger brother, 24, went to the USA two
years ago to escape neighborhood gang
violence that once took 11 lives in two
months, she says.
Lemus'
decision to strike out alone on Jan. 25
was part of her family's dream. She
planned to find work, send money home
regularly and return after a few years.
"Some
Salvadoran families see the United
States as their only option for
survival," her father says. "Once
Estella made it to the other side,
everybody was going to be better off."
Lemus
crossed through Guatemala and Mexico on
foot, by bus and by hitching rides. Just
south of the U.S. border, she found a
smuggler taking a group of migrants to
Houston. She paid him $4,000: $1,000
from her boyfriend, and $3,000 her
family borrowed on their house at 20%
interest.
She
recounts a harrowing trip: She walked
for days without food. She slept in
temperatures so cold her hair froze. She
drank from cow troughs. She has scars
from horsefly bites, thorns and wire
fences. A woman in the group nearly
drowned crossing the Rio Grande.
The Border
Patrol caught her near Falfurrias,
Texas, on Feb. 8.
Lemus says
it all soured her on going to the USA
illegally. "I don't want to take my
chances again on the trip, but I might
change my mind down the road because of
this mortgage," she says through a
translator. "If they take away the
house, where will we live?"
Motivation remains strong
Berrios,
Lemus' neighbor, says he has mounting
debts. Because visas are too difficult
to get, he says, he'll keep trying to
sneak into the USA.
A
construction worker who was on the same
deportation flight, Berrios can make $20
a day, but sometimes he goes months
without work.
"Look at
the reality of our house and how we
live," he says of his crime-infested
neighborhood and unfinished home, which
overlooks a river whose polluted water
runs purple, red and brown. When family
members go to the grocery, he says, they
run to minimize chances of being robbed.
For now,
the home's windows are boarded with
plywood, and the walls and floors are
bare, but Berrios says he dreams of
making it a beautiful sanctuary for his
family: girlfriend Luz Cardenas, 31; her
daughters Stefany, 12, and Katherine, 9;
and their son, Anthony, 5.
In
January, his mother took a $7,000
mortgage on her house to finance his
trip to join four brothers and a sister
in the San Francisco Bay Area. He was
caught in Texas. "I'll try again because
I have no other way to pay back the
money," he says through a translator.
Berrios
says he doesn't want to stay in the USA.
He wants to earn money for his family
and return to El Salvador to open a
business. He's unapologetic about his
plans. He says people like him just want
to give their families a chance to rise
out of poverty.
As he
surveys his threadbare home, Berrios
says he's missing a key ingredient for
happiness: "I have love and health, but
I'm missing money. … That's what's
motivating me to try to cross again."