Dems do More Listening than
Talking at Iowa Brown and Black Forum
DES MOINES, Iowa (By Jennifer
Jacobs, Des Moines Register) December 2, 2007 — The people
got more microphone time than the politicians.
Five Democratic
presidential candidates who spoke at the Heartland Presidential Forum Saturday
in Des Moines could do little more than nod and listen as person after person —
mostly out-of-state residents — shared emotional stories of perceived injustice.
And the audience of 3,600
did not hesitate to express emotion. As they listened to descriptions of loss of
health insurance, the stench of a nearby factory farm, or a family split up by
immigration officials, the crowd frequently yelled out: "That ain't right!" and
booed.
Hillary Clinton, a U.S.
senator from New York, felt the heat of their displeasure after Billy Lawless, a
Chicago immigration rights organizer, asked her if she'd commit to giving
undocumented workers a path to citizenship in her first 100 days as president.
Clinton, who spoke by
telephone, said immigration reform is a top priority.
But Lawless pressed her,
asking if she'd do it in the first 100 days.
Clinton said it's up to
Congress to pass such reform, but as president she would do as much as possible.
The crowd booed, apparently
upset that she wouldn't commit to a 100-days promise.
Chris Dodd, a U.S. senator
from Connecticut, was the next candidate to get that question, and he quickly
answered: "Absolutely, absolutely." "One of the great sources of our wealth and
strength of our country has been the diversity of our people," Dodd said. "We've
never done anything worthwhile as a nation when we've done it out of fear and
hate." Saturday's crowd was hardly just caucus-eligible Iowans. People were
bused in from Missouri, Kansas, Illinois and Minnesota, and organizers said
people from 33 states were represented as part of a kickoff to the Campaign for
Community Values.
The forum was hosted by
Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement and Campaign for Community Values, a
movement that includes about 100 community organizations.
Only one Republican,
businessman John Cox, responded to the invitation, but the hosts' lawyers
advised against a solo member of one party because it would appear to be an
endorsement.
Also in attendance were
former North Carolina Sen. John Edwards, Illinois Sen. Barack Obama and Dennis
Kucinich, a representative from Ohio.
Edwards listened to Virgene
Martin of Bridgewater tell about 400 people banding together to fight a factory
farm. They failed, and the hog operation is now located next to Martin's own
family farm.
"What's happening is these
big corporate farming operations, and big multinational corporations that are
taking over farming in America. We see what they're doing to destroy our land,"
Edwards said. "We see what they're doing to destroy our people and take away our
assets." Edwards, a former trial lawyer, said he beat them in the courtroom,
"and I'll beat 'em again." Irlanda Helgen of Marshalltown got teary-eyed telling
Kucinich about a father of five whose wife left for work one day and never came
back because of an immigration raid.
"There's no illegal human
beings," Kucinich said in English and Spanish.
Kucinich gave a fiery
answer about his plan to move the country away from reliance on coal. He talked
about a "full-employment economy," where everyone has a job, as well as health
care for all, and education for all, from age 3 through college.
And he got wild applause
when he said: "We must give those who come to this country a path to
legalization." Emira Palacios of Wichita, told Dodd she came to the United
States 22 years ago as an undocumented worker. She has spent more than $15,000
during the process of becoming a citizen, and she and her 18-year-old son will
vote for first time in the next election.
Dodd said the country has
to "have secure borders, obviously." Later, a moderator cut him off when his
answer was over two minutes.
"I get more time here than
I get at those debates, though, I can tell you that," Dodd said, chuckling.
Deidra Lewis of
Massachusetts, addressing Obama, said her daughter woke up with a burning
feeling in her eyes one day. Lewis had to cut back her work hours to deal with
her daughter's rare eye disease. In January, she lost her health insurance.
But she enrolled in the
State Children's Health Insurance Program, and the public program made the
difference between a child going blind or keeping her eyesight.
"Can you look into
Alexsiana's eyes and tell me don't all God's children deserve medical care?" she
asked.
Obama said yes. Alexsiana
crossed the stage to hug him. The audience couldn't hear what he whispered in
her ear.
Obama vowed to have a plan
in place for health insurance for all Americans by the end of his first term as
president.
After a string of stories
told by people from the Bronx, Cleveland, Mississippi, South Carolina and
California, Debra Carr told Obama she is from Des Moines.
Obama immediately said: "I
want you to caucus for me."