MAIN
STREET, USA (By
Louis Uchitelle,
Andrew Martin
and Stephanie
Rosenbloom, NYTimes) October
6, 2008 —
Cowed
by the financial crisis, American
consumers are pulling back on their
spending, all but guaranteeing that
the economic situation will get
worse before it gets better.
In response to the falling value of
their homes and high gasoline
prices, Americans have become more
frugal all year. But in recent
weeks, as the financial crisis
reverberated from Wall Street to
Washington, consumers appear to have
cut back sharply. Even with the
government beginning a giant bailout
of the financial system, their
confidence may have been too shaken
to resume their free-spending ways
any time soon.
Recent figures from companies, and
interviews across the country, show
that automobile sales are
plummeting, airline traffic is
dropping, restaurant chains are
struggling to fill tables, customers
are sparse in stores.
When the final tally is in, consumer
spending for the quarter just ended
will almost certainly shrink, the
first quarterly decline in nearly
two decades. Many economists, who
began the third quarter expecting
modest growth, now believe the
cutbacks are so severe that the
overall economy did not expand
either, and they warn that a
consumer-led recession could be more
severe than the relatively mild one
earlier this decade.
“The last few days have devastated
the American consumer,” said Walter
Loeb, president of Loeb Associates,
a consultancy, who said he worried
that the constant drumbeat of
negative news about the economy was
becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
“They all feel poor.”
For some Americans, the pain is
already acute: jobs disappeared at a
faster clip in September. For many
others, day-to-day finances are fine
for now, but the financial outlook
is uncertain: 401(k) accounts are
dwindling, loans are hard to get and
house prices continue to fall.
Claudia Prindiville, a 41-year-old
mother of three, is among those
feeling anxious. Shopping at a
Talbots store in Chicago’s northwest
suburbs, she said her own family’s
finances had not yet suffered.
Still, she pulled out a coupon to
buy a two-piece sweatsuit, and at
The Children’s Place she bought
pants and shirts from the sale rack.
“All the talk about how bad it is
out there has started getting in my
head,” she said. “I still need to
shop for my kids’ school clothes,
but I am definitely buying less for
myself.”
Consumer spending, which accounts
for nearly two-thirds of the
economy, grew modestly earlier in
the year but fell in July and August
on an annualized rate. When the
government releases quarterly
numbers this month, they are
expected to show that consumer
spending shrank 3 percent or more.
That would be the first quarterly
decline since 1990, ahead of the
1991 recession, and the steepest
since 1981.
According to interviews with
shoppers, analysts and company
executives, the impact of the
financial news of the last two weeks
has been palpable in many corners of
the country, from car dealerships,
which endured the worst month for
sales in 15 years, to the flashy
casinos of Las Vegas, where spending
at luxury restaurants and stores and
at gambling tables has gone from bad
to worse.
“In the last few days, there has
been a huge drop-off in foot traffic
and almost zero sales,” said Gil
Colon, sales manager at Villa Reale,
a high-end art and furniture store
in Las Vegas, who has laid off five
sales people in the last five
months, leaving three.
“People have lost their confidence.
They have no buying power. They are
losing their retirements, their
vacation funds, and they are scared
to commit to buying anything,” he
said.
The picture is just as grim at
suburban malls and city boutiques,
where traffic is disappearing as
retailers brace for what many
predict will be a dismal holiday
shopping season. Some have responded
by reducing the number of sales
people or their hours.
Taking a break outside an Office
Depot store in suburban Chicago,
Dave Cargerman, a 25-year-old sales
clerk, said his hours had been cut
back. “We got killed during the
back-to-school sales,” Mr. Cargerman
said. “And that time of year is
usually our bread and butter.”
Nearby, employees at Lattof
Chevrolet were preparing to close
the doors this month on a business
that opened in 1936. It may not be
the last dealership to go: the
percentage of people saying they
expect to buy a car in the next six
months, on a three-month moving
average, has fallen to 5 percent,
the lowest figure since the
Conference Board started asking
about such plans in its consumer
confidence survey, in 1967.
“We’re not selling S.U.V.’s and
trucks at all,” said Raul Trejo, 24,
a mechanic. “We saw it coming.”
The situation is so uncertain that
some retailers are simply not even
trying to estimate their sales. Pier
1 Imports and Circuit City stores
recently withdrew their guidance to
Wall Street about earnings and said
they would not offer any more
predictions this year.
At a retail conference in New York
on Thursday, Michael W. Rayden,
chairman and chief executive of
Tween Brands, which owns the Limited
Too and Justice chains, spoke about
consumer fears. “As I travel around
the country and listen to moms and
little girls, it is amazing how much
even these 10-year-old girls are
aware that something is going on,”
he said. “Mom is saying, ‘I can’t
afford that.’ ”
Even Apple, maker of the iPhone, is
not immune as concerns mount about
consumer electronics. The stock of
Apple ended the week down 19 percent
after two stock analysts suggested
that the rapid cooldown in consumer
spending would put an end to the
company’s hot sales streak.
Casual dining restaurants, which
have struggled in recent years
because of a glut of restaurants and
higher-quality fare at fast-food
chains, have taken a beating already
this year, forcing the Bennigan’s
chain to close and leaving several
others struggling. “I think
September could be the worst month
of the year, and we’ve had a lot of
bad months,” said Lynne Collier, an
analyst at KeyBanc Capital Markets
who covers the restaurant industry.
At a Chili’s Grill & Bar in the
Arlington Heights suburb of Chicago,
Nichol Bedsole, a 23-year-old salon
manager, said she used to eat at
places like Chili’s at least once a
week but no longer does.
“Now it’s more like twice a month,
and it’s somewhere cheap, like
Subway,” she said. “I have a lot of
bills to pay.”
Consumers are cutting back on air
travel, whether for business or
pleasure. Passenger volume is
dwindling even faster than airlines
can sideline planes and cut poorly
performing routes. At American
Airlines, domestic passengers flew
11.7 percent fewer miles in
September, while the airline cut 9.4
percent of domestic seats.
The consumer slowdown in recent
weeks comes after spending drops in
July and August, when tax rebates
came to an end. The financial shocks
on Wall Street accelerated the
decline, along with limits on
consumer credit imposed by some
banks.
“Consumers have become quite
concerned that the recession, which
they think is already under way,
will last longer than they
anticipated and will be deeper,”
said Richard Curtin, director of the
Reuters-University of Michigan
Surveys of Consumers, describing the
most recent poll. “They see their
worst fears coming true.”
In addition, household net worth,
which greases spending, fell $6
trillion over the last year, with $1
trillion of that in just the last
four weeks, said Mark Zandi, chief
economist at Moody’s Economy.com.
Less than a month ago, Nigel Gault,
chief domestic economist at Global
Insight, a forecasting service,
predicted that domestic economic
output would rise 1.2 percent in the
third quarter. “At the moment I’m
running close to zero,” he said,
“and maybe a negative.”
Of course, the economic malaise has
not yet hurt all businesses. It has
even been good for some.
Entertainment and media executives
remain optimistic about sales of
movie tickets, DVDs and games. At
Nintendo of America, the popular Wii
video game consoles are still
selling briskly at about $300.
“My view is that when consumers get
concerned about their nest egg, or
their country, they need
entertainment,” said Bo Andersen,
president and chief executive of the
Entertainment Merchants Association,
which represents distributors and
retailers of home entertainment
products.
And as fewer people eat at
restaurants, food is flying off the
shelves at grocery stores. David
Driscoll, a stock analyst for
Citigroup, said the shares of big
food companies have risen about 17
percent this year. By contrast, he
said, the restaurant sector is down
4 percent.
“The alternative of restaurants is
buying groceries and eating at
home,” he said, “and right now,
that’s an attractive alternative.”
Daniel Kimble, 31, was putting Mr.
Driscoll’s theory into practice on
Friday. An independent trucker from
Oklahoma, he stopped his rig outside
a Wal-Mart in Cleveland on his way
to a nearby factory.
Mr. Kimble ticked off a long list of
his money-saving steps, from driving
his pickup truck less to using less
laundry detergent to buying fewer
clothes. And he has stopped eating
at restaurants on the road, which is
why he was parked at Wal-Mart.
“I’m going in to buy some lunch meat
and some bread, whatever’s cheap,”
he said. “I’ve got to save money,
you know?”