The more
than 20 pastors wrote a
letter to the state's
top officials, urging
them to consider
immigration laws that
preserve human dignity.
"We must uphold the law,
but when laws are used
to raid churches and
church events and
separate children from
families, then it
indicates that something
is wrong with these
laws," said Gary
Kinnaman,
pastor-at-large of the
6,000-member Word of
Grace church in Mesa.
The letter is noteworthy
because many of the
pastors who signed it
come from largely White,
conservative,
evangelical Christian
churches. It follows a
letter from other
mainstream Protestant
and Jewish faiths
condemning recent raids
by Maricopa County
Sheriff Joe Arpaio.
In the recent past, most
of the outcry against
immigration crackdowns
has come from Hispanic
religious leaders or
from pastors on the left
side of the religious
spectrum, experts say.
The pastors said in the
letter that they were
concerned by the
mean-spirited response
that many local and
state officials have
taken toward illegal
immigrants after
Congress failed to pass
reforms last year. They
said the decision to
speak out is based on
Bible Scriptures and the
teachings of Christ to
"welcome the stranger."
The letter was sent to
Gov. Janet Napolitano,
Senate President Tim Bee
and House Speaker James
Weiers and the Arizona
State Legislature.
It gave no specifics,
and the pastors declined
to give any, but the
letter was clearly aimed
at Arpaio's ongoing
crackdowns as well as at
a steady stream of laws
passed or introduced in
the Legislature to drive
illegal immigrants from
Arizona.
Last week, sheriff's
deputies raided three
Valley fun spots and
arrested nine people as
part of an investigation
into illegal hiring
under the state's
employer-sanctions law.
The raid came just weeks
after a series of crime
sweeps by the Sheriff's
Office, mostly in
largely Hispanic
neighborhoods. They
resulted in the arrests
of scores of illegal
immigrants.
"Unfortunately, a number
of local and state
officials have responded
by engaging in a public
conversation that is
dividing our community,
confusing enforcement
procedures and creating
an unwelcoming spirit
for many seeking to make
Arizona their home," the
pastors wrote.
Arpaio has vowed to
continue the crackdowns.
State Rep. Russell
Pearce, R-Mesa, the
author of many of the
anti-illegal-immigration
bills, denied that the
laws have been
mean-spirited.
"I have always said we
must enforce our
immigration laws with
compassion but also with
integrity and without
apology," Pearce said.
He chastised the pastors
for focusing on illegal
immigrants and ignoring
the crimes committed by
such immigrants.
"Where is the compassion
for the victims of
people crossing the
borders every day?"
Pearce said.
Patty Kupfer is with
America's Voice, a
pro-immigrant group in
Washington, D.C., that
is pushing for
comprehensive reform.
She said White
evangelical leaders in
growing numbers are
speaking against the
harsh tone of the
current immigration
debate. The trend is
significant because
White evangelicals hold
political clout among
Republicans, who have
spearheaded many of the
recent get-tough
proposals.
"I'm not saying they are
the key to passing
comprehensive
immigration reform, but
they are one of the
keys," she said.
Still, many White
evangelical pastors have
remained silent about
the issue for fear of
alienating many of their
conservative members,
she said. The silence of
some church leaders
belies at times
extensive efforts to
reach out to Hispanics,
including undocumented
immigrants. The Catholic
Church, for example, is
reaching out heavily to
Hispanic immigrants, but
Phoenix Bishop Thomas J.
Olmsted has been
criticized by some
Hispanic leaders for
not taking a more public
stance against the
crackdowns.
Church leaders declined
to comment. Instead,
they pointed to a
pastoral letter Olmsted
wrote calling for
compassionate
immigration reform and a
statement he made in
April on the diocese Web
site denouncing Arpaio's
sweeps.
Sandy Mason, pastor of
Desert View Bible
Church, a mostly White
evangelical church in
north Phoenix, is one of
the pastors who signed
the letter calling for
more compassionate
treatment of illegal
immigrants. He said he
has experienced a
backlash from some
members. Still, "to be
silent is to be
irresponsible," Mason
said, "and to embarrass
God."






