the Andrea
Gail, which disappeared without a trace with
all six crew members aboard.
It
was the storm of the century. A tempest created by so rare a combination
of factors meteorologists deemed it "the perfect storm." When it struck
in October 2091, there was virtually no warning.
No
one is prepared for the Hispanic storm but the Hispanic storm is coming
Three weather systems are now forming: The first weather system forming
is changing
City of Phoenix Police Order 1.4, the second weather system forming
is City of Phoenix
discrimination as evident by the lack of Hispanic middle and executive
managers, and now the third weather system forming is exposing City
of Phoenix double standards (Tracey Short) and countless Hispanic
workers degraded and abandoned with total disregard of human and labor
rights.
The
Perfect Storm — in Phoenix's case, the force of humanity demanding an
end to discrimination by white employees on American Hispanic employees.
Discrimination prevalent throughout the City of Phoenix oozing latent
effluvium dispersing its stench nourished daily by victimizing City of
Phoenix American Hispanics.
The
count is now 43 emails from Phoenix city workers detailing a rampant
blatant disregard for the dignity of City of Phoenix American Hispanic
employees.
The
count now is more than 100 persons ready to join ALEC.
Last
week Hispanic News did battle with the City of Phoenix as it stonewalled
the discovery of information of one of its employees — Tracey Short, the
Canadian hired by the City of Phoenix as the assistant director of the
Phoenix Convention Center.
The
Merriam-Webster dictionary defines stonewalling: To engage in delaying
tactics; Stall; To be uncooperative, obstructive, or evasive; To resist
or rebuff.
"I
want you to stonewall it, let them plead the Fifth Amendment." — Richard
M. Nixon.
With
the publishing of
City of Phoenix, Cunning Discrimination and Highly Effective, on
January 8, I received four emails and three telephone calls from former
employees of the City of Phoenix who cited special treatment for Tracey
Short, assistant director of the Phoenix Convention Center. The claim is
Tracey Short received financial assistance to obtain an immigration work
visa or her immigration work visa was modified in some regard. It is
also conceivable Tracey Short did not have or does not have a work visa
to work in the United States.
Telephone calls on January 8, to Tracey Short were not returned. On the
same day I called David Richert, senior executive
assistant to the city manager and responsible for the Phoenix Convention
Center. Richert did not take my calls.
On
January 9, I called Frank Fairbanks, Phoenix city manager, who took my
call. I informed Fairbanks, Richert was not taking my calls and I wanted
to know if mayor and council had approved any item concerning Tracey
Short and specifically, had Tracey Short received assistance in
obtaining a work visa by having the City of Phoenix pay for said
services to an immigration attorney.
Fairbanks responded, "I have no knowledge but Richert would know."
Fairbanks said he would have Richert return my call.
Hispanic News supports Tracey Short receiving financial assistance to
obtain immigration documentation so long as all city employees are
afforded the same benefit but the question of double standards arises in
regard to other workers — are Hispanic workers offered this benefit if
needed.
On
January 9, David Richert called to inform me he would provide the
information "tomorrow."
On
January 10, I called Richert to find out if the information was
available. I did not get passed Melissa his secretary.
Later on January 10, David Richert called me to tell me to submit a
Request for Public Records to David Ramirez.
With
the inefficiency of city staff and suspecting a cover-up, I decided to
find the information myself. On January 10, I called the City Clerk's
office and asked for a search of any request for assistance for Tracey
Short taken to the Mayor and Council for approval. Within seconds, the
computer search located a request had been taken to mayor and council 1
1/2 years ago asking for approval to hire Tracey Short at a higher rate
of pay than had been advertised. Mayor and council approved the request.
This city clerk
computer search found only one item. I have some experience of how a
city works being a former department head. I know a city department head
could have authorized the expenditure of city funds without anyone in
the city manager's office or for that matter, mayor and council knowing
about the expenditure.
Since the possible
expenditure to obtain immigration services for Tracey Short did not go
before mayor and council, the only way to find this expenditure,
assuming there was a expenditure, is to go to the finance department and
search all Phoenix Convention Center expenditures. This assumes it did
not come from the city manager budget. Of course, the Phoenix Convention
Center would have this information but it is doubtful, the Convention
Center will release this information considering Tracey Short did not
return by calls and on each occasion, I left a message for Short as to
the reason for my call.
Returning to my
notes of my conversation with Fairbanks, either
Fairbanks is suffering from early onset Alzheimer's in not
remembering an item considered by mayor and council regarding Tracey
Short or Fairbanks lied as part of a cover-up or he is sending Richert
to the lions.
If I succeeded in
finding out about an item placed before the mayor and council, surely
the city manager, if he had wanted to, could have made a request for
this information concerning Tracey Short.
On
January 10, I called the Washington D.C. office of U.S. Immigration and
Customs Enforcement (ICE) to report the possible infraction of Tracey
Short not having proper documentation. I emphasized I did not know this
to be a fact but four individuals were adamant in stating Tracey Short
is undocumented. The Washington D.C. ICE office referred me to the
Phoenix ICE office to report the possible infraction.
In
the event ICE proceeds to the Phoenix Convention Center to arrest Tracey
Short for deportation, the whole world will know Tracey Short has no
documentation.
The
important question still remains to be answered: Did the City of Phoenix
pay for immigration services for Tracey Short? If the answer is yes, has
the City of Phoenix offered this benefit to all city employees who need
assistance?
On
January 1I, I received the following email:
Hello Mr. Garrido,
David Ramirez is working with David Richert on the information you
requested and is happy to provide it to you. As with other, similar
information, please fill out the public records request form and David
will forward the information to you accordingly...thanks!
We apologize for any delay and inconvenience this may have caused you.
Lisseth Leon,
CMO-PIO
On
the same day, I filled out the form and emailed it back with my
signature.
On
January 12, I called Fairbanks but he did not accept my call.
To
date, the City of Phoenix has not provided information to answer: Did
the city pay for immigration services for Tracey Short? It is obvious,
there is information someone does not want disclosed.
Sidebar: There
used to be a picture of Tracey Short on the Phoenix Convention Center
website.
The picture has
been deleted. Is this a sign of things to come?
Does
AFSCME provide adequate representation for American Hispanics?
On
January 14, Hispanic News published the major headline of the day:
AFSCME endorses Hillary Clinton for President. I visited the offices of
AFSCME on 16th Street and Indian School Road to see if I could interview
the person in charge of the office about the AFSCME endorsement.
The
old man who answered my ringing the buzzer at the wrought iron front
gate opened the office door and stood between the front office door and
behind the wrought iron front gate taking a hard look at me as he asked
what I wanted. Not a cordial, "May I help you?" But a stern, "What do
you want?" I felt like I was back at Pruitt's with my brown face
standing on the wrong side of the street.
I
told him about the Hispanic News headline of AFSCME endorsing Hillary
Clinton and I wanted to speak to the person in charge but then he asked
me, "So what do you specifically want?"
I
repeated, "I would like to interview the person in charge of the office
for an article Hispanic News is drafting."
The
old man responded, "I am the boss."
Sensing I was not getting anywhere with this old white man, I then
stated, "I just spoke to the Washington D.C. national office of AFSCME
speaking with assistant political director Linda Canan to see if
Hispanic News could work with AFSCME supporting Hillary Clinton for
president. The assistant political director responded she would have
Lawrence R. Scanlon, Jr., AFSCME director of the union's Political
Action Department call me from Las Vegas. The assistant director said
AFSCME would be very interested in having Hispanic News work with AFSCME
to influence the Hispanic vote to elect Hillary."
Name
dropping worked but it was all true. The old man said, "You better speak
to the president," as he opened the wrought iron front gate to let me
in.
Nancy Gray, the president of AFSCME Local 2960, was gracious but told me
I needed to talk to Sheri Van Horzen, President, Arizona State Employees
AFSCME Union, Local 3111.
My
conversation with Gray continued. To my astonishment I learned AFSCME
employees are also employees of the City of Phoenix. I think the axiom
"one never bites the hand that feeds you" is self-evident of the AFSCME
conflict of interest. To compound the problem, the AFSCME staff I met
and observed at 16th Street and Indian School Road are all white senior
citizens who sat around drinking coffee, eating donuts, and gossiping on
the telephone.
The old man who
called himself the "boss" sat next to me and read the newspaper as I
spoke to Gray. I wondered that day if I had worn a tie and was a "white"
person, if the old man would have stood guard until he was satisfied I
was acceptable to enter the AFSCME office.
If I had been a
AFSCME member working for the City of Phoenix wanting to file a
discrimination complaint, I would have had to dance on the table top
before I would have been allowed into the office to file a complaint.
Racism is
encountered at Pruitt's each Saturday. On January 14, racism raised its
ugly head at AFSCME as a wrought iron gate separated me and the old man.
This behavior is not acceptable for a labor union that is supposed to
represent Hispanics. This old man needs to be fired. The
wrought iron front gate needs to be removed.
It
is inconceivable this staff will ever prioritize representing American
Hispanics complaining of discrimination found within the City of
Phoenix.
On January 22, I
will send an email to everyone at the national AFSCME Washington D.C.
office to share my experience with the Phoenix AFSCME office on 16th
Street and Indian School Road.
When
I worked for the City of Tucson, I became a member of AFSCME. To my
knowledge, AFSCME Tucson never provided anyone assistance with
discrimination complaints.
In Phoenix, what
history does AFSCME have in addressing injustices? The problem of
inadequate Hispanic representation among middle and executive managers
has been the case for countless years. Did AFSCME ever address this
issue? The knowledge of double standards concerning Tracey Short has
been around for one and half years. Did AFSCME question this double
standard of inequality? Regarding countless incidents of specific
individual discrimination complaints at the City of Phoenix, what is the
track record of AFSCME successfully addressing any of these incidents?
It is evident,
AFSCME does not represent City of Phoenix Hispanic employees. Hispanic
News has come to the conclusion, AFSCME across the United States does
not serve the needs of Hispanic public employees.
Does
the Phoenix Equal Opportunity Department provide adequate representation
for American Hispanics?
There is a Phoenix department called Equal Opportunity but many who
emailed or telephone me citing a discrimination complaint stated the
Equal Opportunity Department is a Black city staff organization and does
not provide advocacy for Hispanic employees. There may be some truth in
this as evident by Blacks being 5.6% of the
Phoenix population and African Americans exceeding parity by holding 7%
of middle and executive manager positions.
This
reinforces what I believe, if someone aggressively promotes the hire of
minorities, it does happen. In the case of African Americans, someone at
the City of Phoenix was aggressive in their hire. My guess it was Carole
Coles Henry.
The
real question is why was a African American hired to head the Equal
Opportunity Department when Blacks only make up 5.6% of the Phoenix
population and Hispanics are 41.2%? One would
postulate
a Hispanic would have been a more appropriate choice to head up the
department. The only conclusion is someone very powerful pushed through
the appointment of an African American to head up the department.
It
appears, no one is presently aggressive in the hire of Hispanic middle
and executive managers. On January 18, I asked Carolyn Gall, the acting
Equal Opportunity Department head, why there are only 13.3% Hispanic
middle and executive mangers when the number should be 41.2% to achieve
parity? Gall responded, "They (Hispanics) are not available."
My
response, "This is the same answer given in the 60s when the question
was asked why there are no Blacks public officials."
Presently when discrimination is directed at a Hispanic city employee,
the Hispanic employee for the most part is required to fight
discrimination by himself.
The
Equal Opportunity Department director's job is now vacant. This position
is key to hiring Hispanic middle and executive managers.
The
next action for Hispanic News and ALEC is to send a letter to the City
Manager and council members on doing the right thing — hiring an
American Hispanic to be the new director for the Equal Opportunity
Department.
Even
more important than having a Hispanic become the new department head for
Equal Opportunity is the appointment of a Hispanic city manager.
Fairbanks is on his last leg and now with his possible cover-up of
Tracey Short, it is time for him to go.
ALEC
will begin searching the United States for a Hispanic city manager to be
recruited to Phoenix. And no — none of the so call pseudo Hispanics who
serve under Fairbanks deserve consideration. The new Hispanic city
manager should clean house and start off with a new slate of Hispanics
committed to equality for all.
Fighting discrimination with a twist — the Tucson model
My
Tucson experience took a different twist. There was discrimination and
there was a dire need for an affirmative action office to pave the way
for Tucson Hispanic employee promotions.
Just
out of the U of A, I started as a city planner and left the City of
Tucson as the economic development coordinator working for the city
manager. My friends did not fare as well as I so I was recruited to do
something to help them.
What I did was start a Tucson Hispanic organization that grew to
1,000 members within a two year period.
As
founder and president, our approach to fighting City of Tucson
discrimination did not include the traditional way things are handled
today by hiring an attorney and filing a complaint against the city.
The
novel approach we used was conventional but it succeeded. We boasted a
1,000 member Hispanic organization which meant 1,000 votes with a
multiplier effect of four.
We
maintained most of us were married. In addition, we had friends, parents
and extended family in Tucson. Thus the 1,000 votes became the base and
another 4,000 votes could be counted on for alignment with the initial
1,000 votes.
The
5,000 person voting block became a considerable force in Tucson.
Using the Sol Alinsky model of not forcing an issue unless we knew
we could win proved to be a very successful strategy of influencing the
nine member mayor and council. We learned to count to five and when we
had five votes, we would present our request to the City knowing we had
the majority of mayor and council votes needed to win.
Our
biggest achievement was the City of Tucson established the City of
Tucson Affirmative Action Office.
The
Tucson model will work in Phoenix. I
recommend everyone read how we succeeded in Tucson. The model we
followed in Tucson will be our strategy for change in Phoenix.
After Tucson came El Paso
On
the day I arrived in El Paso to head up economic development for the
City of El Paso, I was contacted by LULAC. I had never even heard of
LULAC prior to that day but I was invited to their monthly meeting and I
accepted.
If I
was successful with Hispanic issues in Tucson, El Paso was more of a
challenge. The night I attended my first LULAC meeting I accepted to
join if I could make changes. The night of my first meeting I made
observations and to my astonishment there were no women. The second
thing I notice, there were no professional persons. The third
observation, there were no young or middle age persons. The fourth
observation came from looking at the check book. There was no money and
the only source of funds was the annual New Year's Eve Dance at the
Civic Center and car washes. The fifth observation there was no action
master plan. The good old boys wandered from item to item with no
agenda. Any member could bring up any topic for discussion. There were
many topics but few germane to LULAC.
And
the end of the meeting, I told LULAC Council 8 of my observations. I
told the men of Council 8, I would join if we could make changes. They
agreed and gave me carte blanche. At the next meeting I became president
of LULAC Council 8.
The
first change I made was to open membership to women. The second change I
made was to recruit young and middle age professional persons — women
and men, mostly city, county, state, federal employees and also bankers,
accountants and business owners primarily from the downtown area where I
worked. The third thing I did was to change how we raised funds. The
fourth thing I did was to establish a political agenda to notify the El
Paso community, we would help elect persons who came to us for help.
And, finally, I laid out a game plan for increasing LULAC's influence in
El Paso.
As
the director of economic development I also wore another hat as the
staff director of the City of El Paso Industrial Development Authority
issuing bonds to finance fixed assets of capital expenditures of land,
buildings, fixtures and equipment for new companies coming to El Paso.
By the time I left the City of El Paso to establish my own manufacturing
company in Cuidad Juarez, we had processed over $200 million in bonds.
The
bonds were placed with the three large banks in El Paso. One afternoon,
I called the three banks and asked for donations to LULAC Council 8. I
asked for $5,000 from each bank. I received a commitment for $14,000
that afternoon and LULAC Council 8 used all the money for scholarships
for El Paso university students. My most gratifying remembrance of El
Paso was a small ceremony giving a $1,000 scholarship to a Hispanic
student to attend Harvard and another $1,000 scholarship to a Hispanic
student to attend Notre Dame. That year LULAC Council 8 came in 3rd in
the nation for giving LULAC scholarships.
LULAC Council 8 became a power house in El Paso politics. All city
council candidates came hat in hand asking for LULAC's blessing in their
candidacy for office. Council 8 also became a power house in Texas
politics. Arizona is not like Texas. I thought LULAC could play an
equivalent role in Arizona but I was wrong. In Arizona, a dead dinosaur
has more life and smarts than Tucson and Phoenix LULAC.
Now
Phoenix
I
know Tucson and El Paso and I also know Phoenix. Actually, I know a lot
about Phoenix by being born and raised in Superior, Arizona. I started
coming to Phoenix with my parents when I was a little kid. Every three
weeks for two years, my parents brought me to my orthodontist on the
corner of 16th Street and Camelback (now a McDonald's). The rest of the
day was spent going to the movies on Central and eating a hamburger at
Big Boy's.
22
years ago, I moved back to Arizona from El Paso. I moved to the Town of
Paradise Valley and then up to Pinnacle Peak where I joined then the
largest real estate development company in the Phoenix area. My
responsibility as v.p. for planning and development included Surprise,
Arizona where we bought 5,550 acres and proceeded on master planning the
parcel for development. All of our consultants were Phoenix based and
with my travels throughout Phoenix, I could tell you what was on every
street corner in Phoenix.
3
1/2 months ago I moved from Scottsdale to central Phoenix to become
involved in Phoenix issues. I came with significant information already
about Phoenix primarily from Hispanic News publishing national news but
also about Phoenix. If there is one dismal failure in Phoenix Hispanic
politics it is the village idiot — Phoenix "do nothing"
Congressman Ed Pastor. The other village idiot is El Paso
Congressman Silvestre Reyes.
ALEC
will duplicate the Tucson and El Paso models to address discrimination
in Phoenix
Borrowing the strategy used in Tucson and El Paso is key to success by
the number of votes ALEC, the Hispanic labor union now forming, can
muster up for each city election.
ALEC
will become involved in city political campaigns using membership dues
to pay for campaigns including advertising to get out the vote and vote
for candidates ALEC has endorsed.
There
are eight districts plus the mayor for a total of nine voting members of
the mayor and council. Five votes on the council are a majority
giving control of all policy managing the City of Phoenix.
Winning 5
districts is achievable using the Tucson model of building a base of
public sector employees and then expanding the base with family, friends
and support from the community.
The
smart thing to do is to open membership to all public sector entities
(city, county, state, and federal agencies — exactly what we did in
Tucson) in Phoenix and also to open membership to small businesses
particularly those involved in procurement, real estate and mortgages
(again, what we did in Tucson to expand our membership). There are many
non-Hispanic women interested in advancing the amount of procurement
provided to women. All will be invited to join. For that matter, anyone
with a voter registration card is welcome to join ALEC.
The
amount of City of Phoenix procurement obtained by Hispanics and others
is smoke and mirrors. In identifying procurement, the City of Phoenix
does not include all procurement the city purchases but only selected
categories.
Even
using only selected categories, the City of Phoenix has a dismal record
of awarding procurement to minorities and women.
According to a report prepared by an outside consultant for the City of
Phoenix, "significant discrimination" is documented as the cause for the
dismal failure of the city's procurement program.
The
City of Phoenix report is available on the Equal Opportunity Department
website at
http://phoenix.gov/CITYGOV/disparty.html
The
report states the following:
(1)
The results of the statistical analysis in Chapter 4 support a finding
that available M/WBEs in the relevant market area are significantly
underutilized and have encountered significant levels of disparity and
discrimination.
(2)
The results of the anecdotal analysis in Chapter 5 support a finding the
City has been: A passive participant in discriminatory practices against
minority and women owned prime contractors in the construction industry;
a passive participant in discriminatory practices against minority and
women owned subcontractors in the construction industry; and a passive
participant in discriminatory practices against minority and women owned
general services and commodities vendors.
(3)
Significant statistical disparities found in Chapter 4 and supporting
anecdotal testimony found in Chapter 5 compel an inference of
discrimination.
The
above report prepared for the City of Phoenix by outside consultants
shows a pattern of City of Phoenix discrimination which supports the
indictment there is significant discrimination found at the City of
Phoenix with the lack of parity of middle and executive managers, the
stonewalling of information concerning Tracey Short and complaints of
Hispanic workers falling on deaf ears with no assistance from the Equal
Opportunity Department.
Lastly, it appears no one actually reads these reports. On January 18, I
called Carolyn Gall, interim director of the Equal Opportunity
Department to inform her I had found an error on page 3 of the executive
summary of the City of Phoenix Equal Employment Opportunity Report 2007.
The
report states:
The number of full-time city employees totaled 14,393 on July 1, 2007,
representing a net increase of 458 or 3.3 percent from July 2006.
Minorities were 40.1 percent of the total, females were 32.2 percent and
males were 67.8 percent. Whites accounted for 59.9 percent of the
current city workforce, Latinos for 27.9 percent, African Americans for
7.2 percent, Asian Americans for 2.0 percent and American Indians make
up 1.1 percent. Employees self identifying with a category of two or
more races were 1.0 percent and those who identified as “Other”
accounted for 0.7 percent.
The error is there are only 39.9% minorities, not 40.1% as stated in the
report.
The
ALEC Game Plan
With
ALEC membership available to city, county, state, federal and small
businesses interested in procurement as well as small businesses dealing
with real estate fraud and others, the 1,000 votes using the Tucson
model goes to 5,000 in Phoenix and with the "multiplier effect" the vote
count goes to 20,000 votes.
With
eight districts this computes to having nearly 2,500 votes in each
district — enough to dominate elections of council members.
In
the event any council member opposed our efforts after being elected
with the help of ALEC, every recall would be successful considering the
small amount of votes required to successfully recall a council person.
As
for the mayor, it does matter who the mayor is for he only has one vote
and it is the city council who approves policy for the City of Phoenix.
Community support would add another 2,000 votes per district. Community
support plus ALEC votes would total 4,500 votes in each district
election. Every candidate would require ALEC support to win in any of
the Phoenix districts. This only includes the votes ALEC brings to each
campaign and does not include the votes each individual candidate brings
to the election. Thus, the City of Phoenix will go from a racist city to
a city that will not have any discrimination because those that
discriminate will loose their jobs with the City of Phoenix.